This site uses cookies to improve your experience. To help us insure we adhere to various privacy regulations, please select your country/region of residence. If you do not select a country, we will assume you are from the United States. Select your Cookie Settings or view our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Cookie Settings
Cookies and similar technologies are used on this website for proper function of the website, for tracking performance analytics and for marketing purposes. We and some of our third-party providers may use cookie data for various purposes. Please review the cookie settings below and choose your preference.
Used for the proper function of the website
Used for monitoring website traffic and interactions
Cookie Settings
Cookies and similar technologies are used on this website for proper function of the website, for tracking performance analytics and for marketing purposes. We and some of our third-party providers may use cookie data for various purposes. Please review the cookie settings below and choose your preference.
Strictly Necessary: Used for the proper function of the website
Performance/Analytics: Used for monitoring website traffic and interactions
372-2021-CCL, 13 December 2022 Marianella Ventura Silva, Centro de Arbitraje, CCL, ITA Reporter for the CCL The arbitral tribunal dismissed the objection of lack of competence filed by the SEDAPAL. PI7947-22, 05 September 2022 Elizaveta Mikaelyan, RAC, ITA Reporter for the RAC A dispute from a contract for the supply of perishable goods.
On its part, the Respondent raised several objections to the jurisdiction of the Tribunal, specifically pointing to several instances of corrupt and illegal acts allegedly committed by Worley at the making and during the operation of the investment. Worley may have willfully failed to monitor and investigate Tecnazul’s corrupt activities.
This contrasts with a more conciliatory approach leading to negotiated outcomes that had previously prevailed in Asia, as discussed further below. By contrast, Australian clauses often include a last step of arbitration if a negotiated price cannot be agreed. ICC, SIAC).
As we reported , in April 2022, the Higher Regional Court in Berlin (“HRC Berlin”) declined Germany’s request to declare an intra-EU claim against Germany as inadmissible (KG Berlin, Decision 12 SchH 6/21, concerning an intra-EU ECT ICSID case, Mainstream Renewable Power et al ).
This was the third installment in the “Affaires d’Etats” series on Investor-State Dispute Settlement (“ISDS”) initiated by Curtis during 2022 PAW. Some are negotiating their investment treaties, particularly free trade agreements (“FTAs”), collectively as a bloc to level the playing field.
Despite negotiations, GBO notified CAI that the agreement was terminated, alleging several breaches. In 2022, the arbitral tribunal ruled that GBO’s termination was unjustified and ordered compensation to CAI. In 2022, judicial scrutiny has been greatly heightened by Belokon v. Onix or Indagro ) to be set aside.
The High Court challenge emanated from the Award that was issued in favour of SNGPL in August 2022, by Chantal-Aimée Doerries, KC (the ‘ Tribunal ’), against QATPL, a public sector company. These are important considerations for contracting parties negotiating the seat of arbitration in any contract.
Key cases around enforcement include CEF and CEG v CEH [2022] SGCA 54 , CVG v CVH [2022] SGHC 249 (as covered in a previous blog post ) and CZD v CZE [2023] SGHC 86. It is noteworthy that more recent analysis in this 2023 blog post showed that the enforcement rate for applications made between 2012 and 2022 had reached 91%.
Professor Giorgetti also noted the lengthy negotiation process of the Codes and underscored the potential for divergence in ethical rules arising from their bifurcated nature. As reported in 2022-in-review on ISDS reform, the voting on the “agreement in principle” of the modernized ECT was initially set for April 2023 after a delay.
A discussion between economist Gustavo Franco (former President of the Brazilian Central Bank) and arbitrator Maurício Almeida Prado (MAP Negotiation and Arbitration, Partner) ensued, dealing with “Business Contracts and Dispute Resolution in Times of Instability,” particularly in the Brazilian context. 3409/21.2T8BRG.G1 [2022]).
A perception of potential bias and cultural differences has expedited this shift, with local parties, often governments or government entities, insisting on local seats in their arbitration clauses when negotiating contracts. Should investors be pushing back on African seat proposals when negotiating arbitration clauses?
Department of State, 2022 Investment Climate Statements: Timor-Leste , [link]. Timor-Leste has since turned its attention towards finalising its land and boundaries with Indonesia and is engaged in ongoing bilateral negotiations to this end [fn]Maritime Boundary Office, Timor-Leste’s Maritime Boundaries with Indonesia , [link].
Countries are enacting new national security laws to limit foreign influence, including China’s 2017 National Security Law; the US’s 2022 National Security Strategy; and the EU’s 2023 Economic Security Strategy. a negotiation period, time limitations, or excluded disputes). As observed by Henry A.
In October 2023, the European Commission published a Non-Paper of Annotations to Model Clauses for Negotiation or Re-negotiation of Member States’ Bilateral Investment Treaties (“BITs”) with Third Countries (“Model Clauses”) (“Non-Paper”).
The Decision joins many other decisions recently issued by Chile’s highest Court that confirm solid and well-founded jurisprudence (see, for example, CS of July 27, 2023, Rol 133.313-2022; CS of October 5 of 2023, Rol No. 71,508-2022; CS of January 16, 2023, Rol 3,545-2022; CS of July 29, 2021, Rol 104,262-2020).
Decision 4A_575/2022 (7 August 2023) concerned a dispute arising from a licence agreement for the operation of a telecommunications network in a part of the southern Republic of Sudan (now the Republic of South Sudan), concluded on 15 October 2003 between C. The agreements were not drafted, negotiated, or signed by the father or his sons.
The Hong Kong Court of Appeal (“ HKCA “) took its first step into the “twilight zone” last year in C v D [2022] HKCA 729 , expressly finding compliance with pre-arbitral conditions in a tiered clause to be a matter of admissibility, as opposed to a matter of jurisdiction (see the blog post here ). Nevertheless, Decision No.
According to its 2021, 2022, and 2023 Annual Reports , ICSID has delivered well over a hundred courses and presentations each year: these include the well-known “ICSID 101”, featuring an introduction to ICSID and general stages of an ICSID arbitration case.
On the last working day of 2022, and “on the eve” of a revised Chinese Arbitration Law, the SPC released its 36th batch of six guiding cases. The FICC then carefully examined the parties’ negotiation history, particularly as it relates to the arbitration clause. The FICC first affirmed its jurisdiction to review this issue.
Japan’s BIT with Bahrain that was signed in June 2022 entered into force in September 2023. Korea rendered in August 2022, our contributor criticized the tribunal’s reliance on an OECD Commentary as “partially incorrect (oversimplified)”—the case is currently undergoing annulment proceedings.
Early this year, the European Union (“EU”) finalized the required internal procedures for the entry into force of the Sustainable Investment Facilitation Agreement concluded between the European Union and the Republic of Angola on 18 November 2022 (“SIFA” or the “Agreement”).
However, as the pervasive abuses of direct awards under the emergency conditions generated by the covid pandemic evidenced in virtually all jurisdictions, dispensing with those requirements, checks and balances comes with a very high price tag for taxpayers in terms of corruption, favouritism, and wastage of public funds.
However, this unfortunate fate was already sealed by the withdrawal notifications by France, Germany and Poland in December 2022, and the preceding decision of some Member States in October to not back the Commission’s proposal for a Council decision on the modernized ECT text for unspecified concerns over protection of fossil fuel investors.
In 2022, Hong Kong legislators continued the reformation of arbitration fee structures. More from our authors: Dealing with Bribery and Corruption in International Commercial Arbitration: To Probe or Not to Probe by Emmanuel Obiora Igbokwe € 190 Arbitration in Egypt: A Practitioner's Guide by Ibrahim Shehata € 190
The ECT Modernization Melt-Down The ECT modernization process developed from 2020 until June 2022 (for a summary of the process since 2017, see here ) and finalized with an Agreement in Principle agreed by all the ECT Contracting Parties. Otherwise, it cannot be applied. Modernization or Destabilization?
In a survey conducted by the Global Arbitration Review (GAR) in 2022 on hearing centre preferences, AIAC was ranked at the forefront among other international institutions, having the highest number of hearing rooms and largest room capacity. Our offices at Sulaiman Building are widely regarded as some of the best ADR venues in the world.
As discussed at the 2022 Trade, Investment and Small States’ conference, the money needed for the project, often does not meet the minimum spending criterion of the funder. Article 8 stops short of providing a basis for any liability or compensation. All are available to watch in full here.
2019-11, Award dated 31 January 2022; Manuel García Armas et al v Venezuela , CPA 2016-08, Award on Jurisdiction dated 13 December 2019; Enrique Heemsen v Venezuela , CPA 2017-18, Award on Jurisdiction dated 29 October 2019).
On December 30, 2022, the Supreme People’s Court of the People’s Republic of China (“SPC”) released its 36th batch of six guiding cases, all of which relate to the judicial review of arbitration awards. In the authors’ view, that remains an open question. As a case in point, in Sun Dingshang v. As a case in point, in Sun Dingshang v.
Nevertheless, a growing number of arbitrations revolve around matters like environmental permits, green incentives, the need for a “social license,” and corruption. Although the UN Report acknowledges this ongoing effort, it falls short in explaining why the changes being negotiated by states are deemed insufficient.
1444 of 2022 of 6 July 2023, which underlined the importance of respecting party autonomy in upholding arbitration agreements. It explained that in typical contract negotiations, once the parties’ proposed terms are accepted, a binding contract is formed. Dubai CoC Case No. Dubai CoC No.
The ICC offices in São Paulo report that almost 85% of their total amount in dispute regards cases with Brazilian state entities [fn] As informed by the ICC’s Counsel during the 2022 Brazilian Arbitration Day organized by the ICC in São Paulo, Brazil. [fn]. Contrastingly, BRAMIA allows some state and social control over dispute proceedings.
The ICC offices in São Paulo report that almost 85% of their total amount in dispute regards cases with Brazilian state entities [fn] As informed by the ICC’s Counsel during the 2022 Brazilian Arbitration Day organized by the ICC in São Paulo, Brazil. [fn]. Contrastingly, BRAMIA allows some state and social control over dispute proceedings.
Sobota highlighted significant legislative measures enacted by the United States, such as the CHIPS and Science Act of 2022 and the Inflation Reduction Act of 2022 , aimed at bolstering domestic technology production and imposing restrictions on semiconductor imports.
The dexterity to combine different ADR services allows dispute resolution tools to be tailored to the dispute and parties at hand, and may give parties the best chance of a negotiated settlement, alongside an opportunity to maintain their business relationships. published in ICCA Congress Series 21 (Edinburgh 2022)).
Shortly before the Investment Protocol’s adoption, in July 2022, the Africa Arbitration Academy issued the Model BIT , which African states can adopt as a standard BIT. Similarly, Article 46.1
In 2022, CIETAC’s practice of third-party funding was recognized in judicial review by PRC courts for the first time (see prior post ). This continues CIETAC’s past efforts to regulate third-party funding. Another novel addition to the 2024 Rules is Article 12.2,
Finally, Szabolcs Nagy highlighted the problems that negotiators of the Member States and the EU are facing in finding a legally sound solution for the withdrawal from the ECT without violating the Rule of Law. Rameau also underlined the need for sustainable FDI and investment retention, in particular in Africa.
However, such developments do open up the possibility of Australia advancing an “investment court” alternative to ISDS when reviewing older IIAs and negotiating new ones. It had reinstated in late 2022 a policy over 2011-13 of not agreeing to ISDS in new IIAs.
01/2022/AHC/ASB) in relation to the long-term concession agreement for provision of postal services in Portugal (the “Concession Agreement”). The Arbitral Award, dated 28 September 2023, was rendered in an arbitration between the Portuguese State and CTT – Correios de Portugal, S.A. Sociedade Aberta (the “CTT”) (proceedings no.
Ongcangco stressed that ADR clauses in borderless contracts should be non-negotiable, as availing of traditional dispute resolutions is impossible. 8, Series of 2022 , which now allows for arbitration as a mechanism to resolve intra-corporate disputes (see a previous post on this development here ).
The program bridged and expanded the discussion that took place at a highly popular program featured in the 2022 edition of WAW on the influence of public international law (“PIL”) on ISDS (read the prior KAB coverage here ). Second, Professor Rivas addressed the potential direct influence of new ICJ judgments on ISDS decisions.
On 16 and 17 October 2022, the Center for Arbitration and Mediation of the Chamber of Commerce Brazil-Canada held its X Arbitration Congress (“X CAM-CCBC Congress” or “Congress”) in Sao Paulo, Brazil. In short time, the AI was corrupted by the users and started sending out violent messages. In addition to litigation, Ms.
Ms Fatás Pérez added that negotiations on the creation of a multilateral investment court would still require significant work. What Happened Since Achmea Was Issued Six Years Ago? Providing a view from an intra-EU investor, Mr Hennessee first summarised the reception of Achmea in two words: disappointment and resignation.
We organize all of the trending information in your field so you don't have to. Join 5,000+ users and stay up to date on the latest articles your peers are reading.
You know about us, now we want to get to know you!
Let's personalize your content
Let's get even more personalized
We recognize your account from another site in our network, please click 'Send Email' below to continue with verifying your account and setting a password.
Let's personalize your content